# #26 — controlled Valhalla highway-preference comparison

Checked 2026-09-19 against `https://valhalla1.openstreetmap.de/route` using exactly two serialized POST requests, separated by more than one second. Public approximate citypoints only; no home/account data. Successful raw response bodies are retained under `tests/fixtures/route-highways-0.json` and `tests/fixtures/route-highways-1.json` relative to OMOX.

The requests were identical except for `costing_options.motorcycle.use_highways`:

```json
{
  "locations": [
    {"lat": -6.981, "lon": 109.14, "type": "break"},
    {"lat": -6.895, "lon": 109.379, "type": "break"}
  ],
  "costing": "motorcycle",
  "costing_options": {
    "motorcycle": {"use_highways": 0, "use_tolls": 0, "use_trails": 0}
  },
  "units": "kilometers",
  "shape_format": "polyline6"
}
```

Identifying headers were `User-Agent: OMOX-private-research/0.3` and `X-Client-Id: omox-private-research`. No further routing requests were made for this comparison.

| Evidence | `use_highways: 0` | `use_highways: 1` |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Provider distance | 58.737 km | 41.760 km |
| Provider time | 6,664.673 s (~111.1 min) | 3,988.727 s (~66.5 min) |
| Toll / highway / ferry flags | All false | All false |
| Warnings | Absent | Absent |
| Decoded geometry vertices | 2,169 | 1,041 |
| Southernmost route latitude | -7.087161 | -6.980983 |
| Northernmost route latitude | -6.895014 | -6.860163 |
| Notable returned street names | Jalan Raya Slawi-Jatinegara; Jalan Pancasila; Jalan Dk Lumpang Sambeng; route 158 | Jalan Banjaran Raya; Jalan Pala Raya; route 1 / Jalan Raya Tegal - Pemalang |

Both shapes decode to identical snapped endpoints: `[-6.980984, 109.140069]` and `[-6.895015, 109.378998]` in latitude/longitude order. Thus the comparison is not explained by different endpoint snapping. The zero-preference shape goes substantially south; the one-preference route uses the Tegal–Pemalang/Pantura street name. These observations come from returned geometry and maneuver names, not a claim that every intermediate road was visually or physically inspected.

Changing this one preference shortened the returned route by **16.977 km (28.9%)** and about **44.6 minutes**. This reproduces the earlier detour and demonstrates that the selected costing preference materially caused a less direct route for these points. It does **not** prove the new route globally shortest, legally current or physically passable.

Regression expectation: accept a valid motorcycle route containing ordinary trunk/Pantura roads when the retained restriction evidence permits it; do not equate all major roads with motorway. Keep independent toll/motorway restriction validation, rather than assuming a high highway preference proves safety or a low preference prohibits such roads. Current upstream summary `has_highway` is set for motorway classification, not every trunk road; see the [provider decision research](/omox/routing-provider-decision/) and [upstream trip-leg builder](https://github.com/valhalla/valhalla/blob/master/src/thor/triplegbuilder.cc). Upstream source does not pin the hosted server's deployed commit.

Fixture integrity (SHA-256 of the encoded `trip.legs[0].shape` string):

- Highway preference 0: `f97bceed098b4296aa540822ad7a42b8b1bfa6fc3b865a8aed88e4aa1ac127b5`
- Highway preference 1: `0ba81f7efe760b9b8bcfb8a47c6dfed25b3ed35053c7477b66f68c59246ded20`

Use these recorded responses in deterministic parser/regression tests instead of repeatedly querying the public service. Distances are observations of this snapshot, not permanent assertions about future provider data.
